Top Platforms for Buying and Selling Comics

Top Online Marketplaces for Buying and Selling Comics

When it comes to buying and selling comic books online, there are several popular platforms that cater to both collectors and resellers. Each platform has its own strengths and weaknesses, making it important to choose the right one based on your specific needs and goals. Here are some of the top online marketplaces for buying and selling comics:


eBay is widely considered one of the best platforms for maximizing selling prices, thanks to its huge potential audience. However, it does require more effort in listing and managing individual comics or short runs. Sellers should be prepared to invest time in creating detailed listings, managing auctions, and handling shipping and customer service. According to Reddit users, eBay is the “biggest hassle” for selling comics, but it can also yield the best prices.


Mercari is a popular alternative to eBay, especially for selling comics in larger lots or bundles. One Reddit user mentioned selling 21 lots on Mercari, priced between $17-$45 per lot. This platform can be a good option for those looking to sell their comics quickly and efficiently, without the need for individual listings.


Comixology, owned by Amazon, is a leading digital comics platform offering a wide selection of digital comics and trades. While Comixology is primarily focused on digital comics, it can be a valuable resource for collectors and resellers looking to stay up-to-date on the latest releases and trends in the industry. According to a Reddit post, Comixology’s “Unlimited” subscription service only covers a limited number of issues for certain series, which may be disappointing for some users. is recommended for buying physical trade paperbacks, thanks to its free worldwide shipping. A Reddit user noted that the prices for physical trade paperbacks on are around $13 per book, making it a competitive option compared to other retailers, especially for those who live in areas without local comic book stores. is known for offering the best deals on brand new physical trade paperbacks in the US. According to a Reddit post, is a good place to find the best prices for new trade paperbacks, making it an attractive option for collectors and resellers looking to expand their inventory.

When choosing an online marketplace for buying and selling comics, consider factors such as:

  • Fees and commissions
  • Audience reach and potential for sales
  • Ease of listing and managing inventory
  • Shipping and handling requirements
  • Customer service and support

By carefully evaluating these factors and selecting the platform that best aligns with your goals, you can maximize your success as a comic book collector or reseller in the online marketplace.

Brick-and-Mortar and Consignment Options

While online marketplaces have become increasingly popular for buying and selling comics, brick-and-mortar stores and consignment options still play a significant role in the comic book reselling industry. These traditional methods offer unique advantages and opportunities for collectors and resellers looking to buy or sell their comics in person.

Local Comic Shops

Local comic shops are a quick and easy way to sell entire collections, although the prices offered may not be as high as other options. According to Reddit users, selling to a local comic shop is the quickest and easiest option, but you’ll likely only receive around 40% of the comics’ value. However, this can be a convenient choice for those looking to sell their collection quickly and without the hassle of listing individual items online.

Comic/Consignment Stores

Comic and consignment stores can help with the selling process, but they may take a higher commission fee compared to selling directly to buyers. As mentioned by a Reddit user, these stores can be a good option for sellers who don’t want to do the research and individual listing themselves. However, it’s important to consider the commission fees and potential impact on profits when deciding to sell through a consignment store.

Comic Conventions and Events

Comic conventions and events provide an excellent opportunity to directly connect with collectors and sell comics in person. These events allow resellers to showcase their inventory, build relationships with potential buyers, and get a sense of current market trends and demands. Reddit users have suggested that selling at conventions can be a great way to move inventory, but it’s crucial to be aware of any legal permits or licenses required, such as business licenses, sales tax permits, and vendor permits.

When considering brick-and-mortar and consignment options for buying and selling comics, keep the following factors in mind:

  • Commission fees and potential impact on profits
  • Convenience and speed of selling entire collections
  • Opportunities to build relationships with buyers and other collectors
  • Legal requirements and permits for selling at conventions and events
  • Pricing strategies and market trends

By carefully weighing these factors and selecting the option that best aligns with your goals and preferences, you can effectively navigate the world of brick-and-mortar and consignment comic book sales to maximize your success as a collector or reseller.

Alternative Selling Channels and Considerations

In addition to the popular online marketplaces and traditional brick-and-mortar options, comic book resellers can explore alternative selling channels and consider various factors to maximize their success in the industry.

Social Media Platforms

Social media platforms like Instagram, Reddit, and Facebook can be valuable tools for reaching out to potential buyers directly, helping resellers avoid third-party fees. As suggested by a Reddit user, checking if there are any local buyers in your area that you can connect with through social media can be a great way to strike deals and save on fees. Additionally, participating in comic book buy-sell-trade groups on Facebook can provide access to a targeted audience of interested buyers.

Checking Sold Listings and Pricing Data

Researching the actual market value of comics, not just list prices, is crucial for setting competitive prices and maximizing profits. Reddit users recommend using resources like GoCollect and eBay’s sold listings to get a better sense of what similar comics have sold for in the past. However, it’s important to note that these prices may not always reflect the current market value, especially for raw, ungraded comics.

Condition and Grading

The physical condition and professional grading of comics can significantly impact their resale value. As mentioned in a Reddit post, a comic listed for $200 in a high grade may only be worth $15 in raw, ungraded condition. Resellers should familiarize themselves with grading standards and consider getting high-value comics professionally graded to maximize their selling potential.

Building Relationships and a Customer Base

Establishing a reputation and loyal following can be beneficial for long-term comic reselling success. As suggested by Reddit users, building relationships with customers at conventions and events, providing excellent customer service, and maintaining an email list for future promotions can help resellers cultivate a dedicated customer base. Consistently delivering quality products and service can lead to repeat business and positive word-of-mouth referrals.

When exploring alternative selling channels and considerations for comic book reselling, keep the following in mind:

  • Leveraging social media to connect with potential buyers and avoid fees
  • Researching actual market values through sold listings and pricing data
  • Understanding the impact of condition and grading on resale value
  • Investing time in building relationships and a loyal customer base

By staying informed, adaptable, and customer-focused, comic book resellers can navigate the ever-evolving landscape of the industry and find success through a variety of selling channels and strategies.

Scroll to Top